Choose another writer in this calendar:
by birthday from the calendar.
||Heraclitus (c.540-c.480 BC)|
Ancient Greek philosopher, perhaps best remembered for his
poetic aphorism – "no one steps into the same river twice."
It is probable that Heraclitus himself did not know the word
"philosophy". He seems to have written only one work (On Nature?),
which apparently consisted of series of epigrammatic remarks. The book, a papyrus roll,
was deposited in the Temple of Artemis in Ephesus. Although
Heraclitus' work is lost, about 120 short fragments have survived in
the texts of later authors, who quoted him, often in order to scorn his
views. In antiquity Heraclitus was called "the Obscure, the Dark".
"The Ephesians deserve to have all their youth put to death, and all those who are younger still banished from their city, inasmuch as they have banished Hermodorus, the best man among them, saying, "Let no one of us be pre-eminently good; and if there be any such person, let him go to another city and another people." (in The Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers, by Diogenes Laërtius, tr. C. D. Yonge, 1853)
Little is know of Heraclitus' life. Moreover, his ideas have survived only in quotations by other ancient authors, or as Bertrand Russell said: "When one thinks what would become of any modern philosopher if he were only known through the polemics of his rivals, one can see how admirable the pre-Socratics must have been, since even through the mist of malice spread by their enemies they still appear great." (History of Western Philosophy, Routledge Classics, 2004, p. 52) Due to his cryptic, oracular style he had a reputation for obscurity; he was something like a Wittgenstein of the pre-Socratics. Socrates himself complained that "it needs a sponge-diver to bring up the truth from those depths."
Heraclitus was born in Ephesus in Ionia (western Asia Minor) into an influential family. His father, Bloson, was a member of the highest local aristocracy. His hereditary class privileges Heraclitus renounced in favor of his brother.
Diogenes Laertios, who lived about seven centuries
later, tells in Lives of and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers
several anecdotes of Heraclitus. According to Laertios, Heraclitus
suffered from dropsy. He "covered himself with cow-dung, hoping to
cause the wet to evaporate from him, by the warmth that this produced.
And as he did himself no go good in this way, he died, having lived
seventy years..." Laertios also refers to Neanthes of Cyzicus who said
that he was devoured by the dogs. It is generally agreed that Laertios'
biographical anecdotes are not so reliable as his doxographic notions.
In Raphael's fresco The School of
Athens (1509-1511), he is portrayed as a solitary figure,
withdrawn from the other philosophers engaged in lively discussion. He stares downwards.
"... each time I recall fragment 91 of Heraclitus," wrote Jorge Luis Borges in 'A New Refutation of Time' (1944-47), "'You cannot step into the same river twice,' I admire his dialectical skill, for the facility with which we accept the first meaning ("The river is another") covertly imposes upon us the second meaning ("I am another") and gives us the illusion of having invented it..." (Selected Non-Fictions by Jorge Luis Borges, edited by Eliot Weinberger, 1999, p. 323) Heraclitus taught that what we think of as things are more accurately understood as processes: "All things flow; nothing endures," he said. Aristotle further argued that if this is true, there can be no knowledge of things which are in a state of flux. Ludwig Wittgenstein, who took a critical look at the famous river-image, stated straightforwardly: "The man who said one cannot step into the same river twice was wrong; one can step into the same river twice." (The Big Typescript: TS 213 by Ludwig Wittgenstein, edited and translated by C Grant Luckhardt and Maximilian A.E. Aue, 2012, p. 304c)
Thales of Miletus held that water is the root of all things, Heraclitus
considered fire to be the primary form of all matter. Everything is in
a state of perpetual change; things come into existence and they then
pass away. "All things are exchanged for fire, and fire for things; as
goods for gold and gold for goods."
Later the Stoics built their theory
of the world and its never-ending cycles on Heraclitean principles. He
thought that the changes occur in a vast cycle of time. There are three
cycles: (i) a time period of 30 years for a human generation; (ii) the
natural cycle of the day; (iii) the natural cycle of the year: 360
The Great Year, when the cycle of time brings things back to their
original positions, covers 10,800 (=30 x 360) solar years. Plato says
in Timaeus that it is the
time when the sun, moon and planets all return to the same relative
position. The Great year is in Heraclitus' cosmology a cosmic
counterpart of the human generation.
Heraclitus had little sympathy for democracy, but in this he
alone; democracy was invented by the urban Athenians, not in the
prosperous Ionia. Most of the spiritual leaders of the fifth and fourth
centuries, with the exception of the Sophists and Euripides, were on
the side of aristocracy and reaction. In the Marxist history of
philosophy Heraclitus has been an acknowledged thinker. He is regarded
as one of the earliest predecessors of the Dialectical Materialism. One
of its central doctrines, derived from Hegel, is that higher truths may
be reached from contradictions. The underlying general law of
development of nature, society, and thought is dialectic. There is a fundamental unity of opposites. From a battle
between ideas – between thesis and antithesis – comes a
synthesis, which perhaps again becomes a link in the dialectical chain.
Both Hegel and Nietzsche had a high esteem of Heraclitus. "There is no sentence of
Heraclitus' that I have not taken into my Logik," Hegel declared. (Nietzsche: Philosopher, Psychologist, Antichrist by Walter Kaufmann, fourth edition, 1974, p. 241n)
Nietzsche said that Zarathustra's and his doctrine of the
"eternal recurrence" might have been taught already by Heraclitus. He
took Heraclitus as an example of "Dionysian wisdom" in the essay Philosophy in the Tragic Age of the Greeks
(1873): "Heraclitus regal possession is his extraordinary power to
think intuitively. Toward the other type of thinking, the type that is
accomplished in concepts and logical combinations, in other words
toward reason, he shows himself cool, insensitive, in fact hostile, and
seems to feel pleasure whenever he can contradict it with an
intuitively arrived-at truth." (Reading Nietzsche through the Ancients by Matthew Meyer, 2014, p. 75)
Heraclitus observed that opposites, such as living and dead,
and sleeping, young and old, are connected by change: without one
contrary the other would not exist.With this line of thought, he had
much in common with Zen Buddhist masters (and Ludwig Wittgenstein) who used koans – riddles – to
train their students. The ultimate law or reality does not change. In
spite of the conflicts
and contradictions, there is a hidden harmony, "a tension of opposites,
like that of a bow of a lyre". Thus "the way up and the way down are
one and the same." The logos, the great transcendental
governing principle of the universe, is common to all.
Heraclitus' logos seems to be synonymous with fire: "Fire is the underlying element: the world is an ever-living fire." The cosmos was not created by gods or mankind, "but it was ever and is and shall be ever-living Fire, kindled in measure and quenched in measure." Most mortals lack understanding of the logos. They are like sleepwalkers unaware of the reality around them. The wise, having heard the logos, agree that all things are one. Heraclitus also wrote, that "the lightning steers the universe." It can also be said, that his own fragments are similar flashes of thought – "I searched within myself," he said. The German philosopher Martin Heidegger tells in Heraclitus Seminar (1993), that on his journey in Aegina he saw suddenly a single bolt of lightning, "after which no more followed. My thought was: Zeus."
For further reading: Selfhood and Rationality in Ancient Greek Philosophy: from Heraclitus to Plotinus by A.A. Long (new edition, 2022); 'Unity in Strife: Nietzsche, Heraclitus and Schopenhauer' by James Pearson, in Conflict and Contest in Nietzsche's Philosophy, edited by Herman Siemens and James Pearson (2019); 'Going with the Flow: Soul and Truth in Heraclitus' by Drew A. Hyland, in A Companion to Ancient Philosophy, edited and with an introduction by Sean D. Kirkland and Eric Sanday (2018); Nietzsche and Classical Greek Philosophy: Beautiful and Diseased by Daw-Nay N.R. Evans Jr. (2017); Doctrine and Doxography: Studies on Heraclitus and Pythagoras, edited by David Sider and Dirk Obbink (2013); The Logos of Heraclitus: The First Philosopher of the West on Its Most Interesting Term by Eva Brann (2011); Remembering Heraclitus by Richard G. Geldard (2000); The Origins of Epistemology in Early Greek Thought: A Study of Psyche and Logos in Heraclitus by Joel Wilcox (1994); Heraclitus Seminar by Martin Heidegger and Eugen Fink (1993); Heraklit heute by G. Nesse (1982); The Art and Thought of Heraclitus by C.H. Kahn (1979); Archaic Logic: Symbol and Structure in Heraclitus, Parmenider and Empedocles by R.A. Prier (1976); Eraclito: Testimonianze e imitazioni by R. Mondolfo and L. Taran (1972); The Pre-Socratic Philosophers by Kathleen Freeman (1966); Heraclitus by P. Wheelwright (1959); The Presocratic Philosophers by G.S. Kirk and J.E. Raven (1957); Doxographi Graeci by Hermann Diels (1879); The Lives and Opinions of Eminent Philosophers by Diogenes Laërtius (1853) - Suomennokset: Herakleitos: Yksi ja sama, 1971 (suom. Pentti Saarikoski)